In the appropriate place...
To create better control of the situation, let's go back to the very basics. It doesn't matter what the age of the dog is, so long as the dog is healthy and ambulatory.
Crates are great things, dogs love them if you haven't abused the crate.
So, if you can't be paying attention to what the dog is doing because you are busy, or the whole family has their heads in the boob-tube, crate the dog.
Do not crate any dog for longer than four hours at a time, because a properly sized crate is for sleeping, not living.
Hint number one! Go outside with them, and I don't care what the weather is or how you happen to be dressed. Go Outside Together.
Now, Stay Outside until you get elimination, then an additional two, TWO, minutes doing something besides running back into the house!
Hint number two! When the dog eliminates and you race his butt back into the house immediately, you will find yourself out there for hours on end waiting for elimination. BECAUSE you just punished the dog for eliminating by taking him directly back into the house. Don't do it!
A. Immediately after a nap
B. Five minutes into a play session
C. Ten minutes after eating
D. First thing in the morning
E. Last thing at night
F. After a car ride
Well, I have covered all the times that I have to go, how about you? Dog is the same. Puppies even more so.
My recommendation is to start with shredded canned chicken. This is the Ace in the Hole of rewards. They only ever get shredded canned chicken when they eliminate outdoors. Dog gets it! By day three, he will drag 'your laziness' outdoors so shredded canned chicken arrives on his lips.
As soon as elimination starts: Name it...
Good Pee Pee
Then, deliver a couple of pinches of shredded canned chicken to those lips while you are praising what just happened (naming it) to the Heavens!
Again! Dog gets it! By day three, he will drag "your laziness" outdoors so shredded canned chicken arrives on his lips.
This of course doesn't have to happen forever, but I would suggest a couple of weeks to drive it home.
I always ask: "Do you want to go outside?"
"Do you want to go pee pee?"
I do this in a higher happy voice, and they race around until I get off my "dead" and onto my "dying" and get them out the door. They love it, and so will you!
All Creatures Country Club